In one of his most unfiltered podcast moments of 2025, Stephen A. Smith stirred controversy by suggesting LeBron James handles criticism differently depending on who it comes from — specifically claiming that LeBron rarely, if ever, confronts white journalists with the same energy he gives Black media figures.

The debate started when Stephen A. revisited LeBron’s recent exchange with Pat McAfee and Brian Windhorst, calling it the only instance he could recall of LeBron publicly pushing back on a white reporter.

“You ever see LeBron go at a white boy?”
“The closest was Brian Windhorst — and even that was light.”

From there, the conversation spiraled into a larger discussion about race, media power, and accountability in sports journalism.

🔥 The Moment That Sparked It

Stephen A. was dissecting LeBron’s reaction to comments made about his son, Bronny James, when he dropped the now-viral observation. He explained that after his own extended monologue about the situation — a 17-to-18-minute segment — he heard through industry channels that LeBron didn’t plan to respond publicly again.

“They told me LeBron wasn’t going to say more about me,” Stephen A. said. “That’s fine. But understand — I got receipts. And I’ll debate facts anytime, anyplace.”

He clarified that his criticism of LeBron wasn’t personal. It was what he called “tough love” — holding one of the world’s most powerful Black athletes to a higher standard.

“I’m a proud Black man,” he said. “Sometimes I gotta call you out because others can’t survive that same mistake.”

To Stephen A., his critiques are never about tearing down — they’re about ensuring younger players don’t repeat the same errors that could derail their careers.

👀 On Bronny, Boundaries, and Backlash

The flashpoint came when Stephen A. commented on Bronny James’ early NBA appearances — particularly after a rough outing against the Philadelphia 76ers.

“He’s not ready yet,” Stephen A. said during the segment.

That single sentence sparked outrage online, with some accusing him of “attacking a child.” But Stephen A. fired back, insisting the critique was about basketball, not Bronny’s character — and certainly not his health or upbringing.

“I never criticized Bronny’s health scare. I never criticized his draft, or his debut,” he explained. “But when you’re on an NBA floor, you’re a player. And if I can’t say you’re not ready — what are we doing?”

He argued that shielding young athletes from honest analysis sets a dangerous precedent.

“If we can’t talk basketball because we’re scared of being called out, then the game stops being honest.”

🧩 Why He Brought Race Into It

Stephen A.’s comments about LeBron’s treatment of different journalists weren’t meant as a personal attack — they were a cultural critique.

“When it’s a Black reporter — me, Jalen Rose, or Shannon Sharpe — the tone is different,” he said. “But when it’s someone white, like Windhorst or McAfee, the energy’s polite. It’s careful.”

He noted that LeBron’s one dust-up with McAfee and Windhorst was still far softer than the kind of back-and-forths he’s had with Black media personalities.

That’s where the heart of Stephen A.’s point lies: that LeBron, consciously or not, adjusts his confrontation depending on who’s asking the questions — and that subtle double standard shapes how athletes engage with the press.

💬 “If You Talk to Me, I’ll Present Your Side”

Smith pushed back at the notion that he picks fights for clicks.

“No athlete or exec can say I didn’t give them a chance to call me,” he said. “If you talk to me, I’ll present your side. If you refuse — maybe you don’t have an argument.”

He also reiterated his policy of public accountability:

“If I’m wrong, I’ll apologize publicly. But I don’t expect that back from LeBron.”

It was a sharp line — not said in bitterness, but in defiance. A reminder that Stephen A.’s entire brand has always been built on transparency, conviction, and the willingness to stand alone when others play safe.

⚖️ Culture Take: Power, Race & Media Dynamics

This isn’t just another celebrity spat — it’s a flashpoint about how power and perception collide in modern sports culture. Stephen A.’s claim exposes a long-standing tension in the NBA media ecosystem: who gets to challenge the stars, and how far they’re allowed to go.

White journalists often get more access and less hostility. Black journalists, even the most established, face sharper scrutiny when they speak candidly about their own.
That’s the imbalance Stephen A. was trying to highlight — not just with LeBron, but with the system around him.

“It’s not hate. It’s accountability. And that’s always gonna make people uncomfortable.”

🚨 Bottom Line

Stephen A. Smith says LeBron James doesn’t keep the same energy with white journalists that he does with Black media figures.
He insists his critique isn’t personal — it’s cultural, rooted in a belief that fair accountability should look the same no matter who’s asking the question.

💬 Final Takeaway:
Stephen A. isn’t backing down. He says he’ll keep challenging superstars with “receipts, respect, and reason” — even if it means standing alone on the mic. Because in his words:

“You can’t claim greatness and fear criticism. And you can’t call me wrong if you won’t even talk.”

👉 For more trending news and viral moments, visit The Urban Spotlight Homepage